PodcastMiles Franklin MediaSteve Penny

“$300 Silver Is Coming” But Not Before THIS Happens: Steve Penny & Michelle Makori

Steve Penny argues that high debt and weakening labor conditions could limit the Fed's ability to sustain restrictive policy, with inflation and eventual money creation more likely than a prolonged deflationary outcome. He sees silver's long-term bull market as intact despite sharp volatility, citing potential investment demand and several possible supply and industrial-demand catalysts while cautioning that near-term prices may move sideways. His forecasts range from triple-digit silver in 2027 to a much larger rally after eventual Fed easing, but he stresses that timing is uncertain and the most bullish path depends on a crisis response.

SilverPrecious MetalsInflationInterest RatesMonetary PolicyMarket Volatility

Preview · 22 more points in the app

Read the Full Summary

Key Takeaways

Steve Penny argues that policymakers may favor inflation and currency debasement over deflation, and that the $40 trillion national debt limits how far the Fed can raise rates: at 10%, he estimates interest costs of about $4 trillion against roughly $5 trillion in tax receipts. He expects a “hike, pause, print” pattern rather than sustained rate increases capable of crushing inflation.

Penny says weakening labor conditions could prompt the Fed to print money, while a 10%–15% stock-market pullback could lead it to pause rate hikes; both are conditional views, not predictions that those events will occur. In his bullish silver scenario, a correction, falling real-estate prices, and near-term deflation could bring forward a Fed reversal and money creation.

Penny says silver remains in a long-term bull market despite its swing from $50 to $120 and back to $55, and compares the current pattern with the 1970s, when a 423% rise preceded a 59-month consolidation and roughly 50% pullback. He also expects sideways trading with volatility and cautions against assuming an immediate runaway move.

Penny argues that investor demand—not industrial demand—would be the driver if silver rose above $100, and that even a small allocation by high-net-worth individuals and institutions could matter if interest spread more widely. He also says the current global debt binge could benefit gold and silver, which he says have historically benefited in such environments.

Silver demand has competing forces: industrial demand is forecast to fall 3% in 2026 as solar manufacturers reduce use or substitute away, while Penny says AI infrastructure, data centers, power grids, and electrification could offset that weakness over time, though not certainly. He also cites opaque, unverified estimates of 15–40 million ounces of annual military demand, with some research suggesting more than 100 million ounces, against about 850 million ounces of annual mine production.

GEO-POLITICS

Critical Mineral — The host says silver was added to the U.S. government's critical minerals list in November 2025. She cites its uses in electrical circuits, batteries, solar cells, medical applications, and defense, as well as its importance to the economy and national security.

“Now, let's keep in mind, Steve, that silver was officially added to the US government's list of critical minerals in November of 2025…”—

ECONOMY

Inflation Preference — Steve Penny argues that policymakers may prefer inflation and currency debasement to deflation because voters may not link rising prices to government spending. Falling stock and housing prices, he says, can lead voters to blame politicians. He expects policymakers to choose debasement over a deflationary outcome.

“They ju if they did I mean it would lead to a deflationary spiral and these central planners and politicians and people in charge they always prefer inflation…”—

Fed Rate Path — Steve Penny argues that the Fed will ultimately tolerate hot inflation rather than risk crushing the economy, drawing a comparison with the pre-Volcker period. He expects a “hike, pause, print” pattern: the Fed might raise rates once or twice more, then pause and eventually resume money creation.

“And memory, it the Fed chairman's name is not coming to mind. I'm not thinking of Volcker…”—

Debt Rate Constraint — Steve Penny argues that the $40 trillion national debt limits how far the Fed can raise rates. At 10% interest, his example implies about $4 trillion in interest costs against roughly $5 trillion in federal tax receipts, with about 80% of receipts going to debt service. He says sustained hikes large enough to squash inflation are not mathematically viable.

“Because with a $40 trillion national debt, every 1% rise in interest rates is 400 billion in tax receipts in tax tax expense…”—

MARKETS

Silver Volatility — Steve Penny says silver's long-term bull market remains intact despite a historic swing from $50 to $120 and back to $55 in a few months. He sees the 1970s as the closest analog, comparing the recent pattern with the 27 months before the 1974 interim peak. After a 423% rise, silver entered a 59-month consolidation and fell roughly 50%.

“Well, I would say the long-term bull market is still intact and this price action while this level of volatility may not have been anticipated…”—

Silver Catalysts — Penny identifies a pause in the Fed's rate-hike campaign as a potential silver catalyst because he expects markets to look ahead to easing. He also watches the Commitments of Traders report: extreme bank short positioning is usually bearish, he says, and he is looking for banks to cover shorts and position for a rally.

“As per your thesis, I think that's one that'll be one of the main drivers. Yes…”—

Debt And Metals — Steve Penny argues that the current global debt binge could benefit gold and silver, which he says have historically performed well in this kind of environment.

“I think this is the greatest global debt binge in all of human history, and silver and gold historically are always the prime beneficiary of this exact environment.”—

FORECASTS

Gold At $15,000 — Steve Penny says gold could ultimately reach $15,000, though it may take longer than many expect. He bases the target on roughly 15-fold average returns in the previous two gold bull markets and says gold could exceed that level.

“I would not be surprised at all to exceed 15,000. 15,000 gold is what you're saying. Correct. Yes. 15,000 gold…”—

Silver's 1979 Surge — Penny predicts silver's equivalent of the 1979 surge, when it rose roughly eightfold in 12 months, could still lie ahead. He says it may be further out than many expect and that downside volatility could persist.

“But the good news is the 1979 moment awaited where silver went up like 8x in 12 short months. I believe our 1979 moment awaits…”—

Easing And Metals Rally — Penny speculates that findings from five Fed task forces due later in 2026 could provide political cover for a pause and eventual easing. He expects easing into mid-to-late 2027 to precede another major move higher in precious metals in early 2028.

“So my operating road map right now is that Fed Chair WH at his first FOMC press conference, he announced the formation of these five key task forces and they're…”—

Coming Up

Michelle opens with Steve Penny's target of $15,000 gold and asks what $300 silver would signal about the monetary environment.

Introduction

Michelle introduces the volatile silver market and Steve Penny, who says the long-term bull market remains intact despite its sharp reversal.

What Happened To Silver

Penny describes silver's decline from above $120 to $55 as a possible 1974-style consolidation, not a change in the long-term bull thesis.

1970s Analog Explained

Penny compares recent silver action with the 1970s: both followed steep advances, and he says a prolonged sideways phase could precede another powerful rally.

Hike Pause Print Roadmap

Penny argues the Fed may hike, pause, then ease as economic weakness and political pressures make restrictive policy hard to sustain.

Debt Math Limits Rates

He says $40 trillion in federal debt makes sustained high rates mathematically difficult, increasing the likelihood of inflation and currency debasement over deflation.

Range Trade And Levels

Penny sees a broad near-term silver range of roughly $60–$100, with $65–$85 more likely, and regards a break above $121 as a renewed uptrend signal.

Signals And Tactics

He tracks Fed policy, bank positioning in COT data, and technical resistance, while describing selective profit-taking as a tactic for volatile markets.

Sponsor Break

Michelle pauses the interview for a channel subscription appeal and a Miles Franklin sponsor message about precious-metals guidance.

Banks Forecasts Vs COT

Penny says bank price forecasts matter less than their futures positioning, which he monitors through the Commitment of Traders report.

300 Silver And 15k Gold

He derives $300 silver from a possible $15,000 gold price and a conservative 50-to-1 gold-silver ratio, while emphasizing that the route there may take time.

Industrial Demand Upside

Penny treats monetary debasement as the main price driver but identifies supply disruptions and possible military purchases as additional upside risks.

Military Demand Wildcard

He views silver as a potential military-demand beneficiary, while Michelle notes industry forecasts for lower solar use alongside growth in AI and electrification.

Solar Thrifting vs AI Buildout

Penny expects solar thrifting and newer technology uses to offset over time, but says investment demand—not industry consumption—is what could drive silver above $100.

Investor Demand Drives Price

Michelle asks whether U.S. weapons replenishment could increase silver use; Penny calls military demand opaque and a plausible but uncertain upside catalyst.

Weapons Restocking Impact

Penny says he cannot verify claims of price suppression tied to defense needs, but believes authorities and banks have incentives to manage precious-metals prices.

Critical Mineral Manipulation Talk

He views CME's new cash-settled 100-ounce silver futures as a step away from physical price discovery, though he expects supply and demand ultimately to prevail.

CME 24 7 Cash Futures

Penny says Western price discovery may remain distorted and discusses a theory that China buys Treasuries while the U.S. manages gold prices to support its accumulation.

East Takes Physical Delivery

He says $300 silver could accompany dollar-priced inflation and rising asset prices, even as goods and assets become cheaper when measured in precious metals.

What 300 Silver Means

Penny sees Fed uncertainty keeping silver rangebound and says debt-service costs, weakening labor, housing stress, or a market correction could force a policy turn.

Fed Uncertainty and Catalysts

He advises long-term physical holders to remain patient and urges active traders to reset expectations rather than assume an immediate surge to $200 or $300.

Investor Mistakes and Timelines

Penny's base case is silver revisiting about $100 in the first half of 2027, then consolidating before a possible breakout above $100–$120 later that year.

Bull Base Bear Scenarios

His bullish scenario is a sharp economic or market scare that prompts earlier Fed easing and money creation; the bearish case is a Volcker-like Fed willing to tolerate pain.

Final Advice and Wrap

Penny says his long-term bearish scenario would require policymakers to let free-market forces work, then advises listeners to use conditional plans rather than rely on forecasts.

Related Episodes

Important Disclaimers

Not Investment Advice: For education only — not financial, tax or legal advice.

AI-Generated: Made by AI from source transcripts and may contain errors.

No Guarantees: Past performance does not predict future results; investing carries risk.

Our Commentary · Request Removal